Religion of the Heart

John Wesley and the Legacy of Methodism in America

Cases 1-4

The Origins and Early History of Methodism

The Wesley Family in Epworth

John Wesley (1703-1791) and Charles Wesley (1707-1788) were born in Epworth, Lincolnshire. Their father was Samuel Wesley (1662-1735) and their mother was Susanna Wesley (1669-1742). Although both Samuel’s and Susanna’s family were connected to Nonconformist movements, they had belonged to the Anglican church. Samuel Wesley, a talented poet and scholar, was the rector of the parish church in Epworth. Susanna Wesley played an instrumental role in their upbringing and education. Correspondence between Susanna and John show that she continued to play a role in his theological development as an adult.

Epworth was geographically and culturally distant from London’s urban landscape and Oxford’s academic setting. Because much of the region was poverty-stricken, hostile to outsiders, and undereducated, it was a difficult environment for the Wesley family to thrive. Susanna gave birth to nineteen children, although only ten survived past infancy. In 1709, the Wesley’s family home caught on fire and the entire family escaped except for the six-year-old John Wesley. John found the bedroom window and two men came to his rescue—one climbing on the shoulders of the other. John’s rescue from the fire had a profound impact on his life. Much later he would refer to himself, using the language of Zechariah 3:2, as “a brand plucked out of the burning.”

The Oxford Holy Club

Oxford University was the location of the first rise of Methodism. John studied at Christ Church, Oxford University (1720-1724) followed by his brother Charles (1726-1733). In 1726, John was elected a fellow of Lincoln College, Oxford University. During this period, Charles started what later became known as the “Holy Club.” John stepped in later as its leader. The Holy Club was initially centered on spiritual growth and academic discipline, but the focus eventually expanded to include social concerns. Members of the Holy Club also included George Whitefield, William Morgan, Benjamin Ingham (1712-1772), John Clayton, and Thomas Broughton.

Samuel Wesley looked to John to take over the Epworth parish and parsonage, but John refused his ailing father’s wishes on the grounds that Oxford was, like nowhere else, the place he can best “promote holiness in [himself] and others.” Whereas John saw Epworth as stifling, he found Oxford to be a fertile ground for ministry. Decades after John left Oxford, he reflected positively on his Oxford days in a letter to Charles: “Let me be again an Oxford Methodist! … I did then walk closely with God, and redeem the time.”

The Wesleys in Georgia

Despite his earlier claim that Oxford was the best place to exercise his ministry, John Wesley readily accepted James Oglethorpe’s invitation to participate in the burgeoning colony of Georgia. In October 1735, John departed for Georgia along with two others from the Oxford Holy Club (his brother Charles and Benjamin Ingham) along with Charles Delamotte (1714-1790). They arrived in February 1736. The voyage to Georgia introduced the Wesleys to the Moravians, who would prove to be a major influence on both brothers. In Georgia, Charles Wesley became Oglethorpe’s secretary, although he was unsuccessful in that role and departed after only six months. John Wesley was initially frustrated with the results of his ministry. He had hoped to establish a primitive Christian community among the native Americans, but his ministry at Christ Church in Savannah distracted him from that goal. Wesley’s strict application of high-church religion proved unpopular amongst many Savannah residents.

John Wesley developed a close relationship with Sophia Hopkey, but John ended the relationship and Sophia married another man. An affidavit by Captain Roberts Williams calls into question Wesley’s overall character as well as his particular behavior with respect to Sophia Hopkey while he was in Savannah. Williams claimed that Wesley “seduced the common persons, there settled, to Idleness,” and “had been guilty of using too great familiarities with Mrs. Sophia Christiana Hopkey.” In August of 1737, the Grand Jury for Savannah charged Wesley with speaking to Sophia Hopkey against her husband’s consent and repelling her from the Holy Communion. After more than three months of trying to defend his actions, Wesley fled by night for Charleston, and from there he sailed back to England. He wrote: “I shook off the Dust of my Feet, and left Georgia, after having preach’d the Gospel there (not as I ought, but as I was able) one year and nearly Nine Months.”

John and Charles Wesley in Savannah – John T. Scott from Candler School of Theology on Vimeo.

John Wesley and Aldersgate

In early 1738, shortly after his return from Georgia, John Wesley fostered a relationship with the Moravian leader, Peter Böhler (1712-1775), who himself was set to depart for a mission in Georgia and South Carolina. At this time, Wesley thought of his faith as weak, but Böhler convinced him that there are no degrees of faith, and so he lacked a genuine saving faith altogether. The Moravians taught that a genuine faith would be accompanied by an unmistakable assurance. On May 24, 1738, Wesley attended a Moravian meeting on Aldersgate Street. There, during a reading from Martin Luther’s preface to the book of Romans, Wesley felt his heart “strangely warmed.” Wesley understood this as confirmation that he possessed saving faith. Still, Wesley continued to struggle with doubts and within a couple of years he departed completely from the Moravian view of faith, opting for a view more consistent with his experience. Though later Methodists often celebrate Wesley’s “conversion” at Aldersgate, Wesley himself did not view the event as a paradigmatic conversion experience.

Providential Deliverance of John Wesley from Fire, Feb. 9th 1709. 1850
Providential Deliverance of John Wesley from Fire, Feb. 9th 1709. Lithograph. Printed by Kellogg & Comstock (Hartford, Conn.), 1850. Based on a painting by Henry Perlee Parker (1795-1873). [RG 020-3]
John Wesley and His Friends at Oxford. Engraving. Based on an 1858 painting by Marshal Claxton. [RG 020-3]
John Wesley's diary from his time in Georgia (1736). [MSS 153]
The Life and Conversation of that Holy Man Mr. John Wesley, during his Abode at Georgia. The Affidavit of M. Robert Williams, of the City of Bristol, Merchant, in relation to Mr. Wesley's Conduct during his Abode at Savannah in Georgia, 1739. [MSS 153]
John Wesley's Aldersgate experience as depicted in Elmer T. Clark, What Happened at Aldersgate (1938) [1938 CLAR]